Imagine strolling into a hidden Melbourne laneway and discovering a restaurant that feels like it's been there forever, yet it effortlessly blends the old-world magic of Italy with the vibrant buzz of modern Australian dining. In a year when Melbourne's culinary scene exploded with creativity, Trattoria Emilia emerged as a standout Italian charmer that still captivates hearts today – and trust me, its journey might just challenge your ideas about what makes a restaurant truly timeless.
Nestled discreetly in an urban alleyway, this 10-year-old eatery strikes a perfect balance between age-old traditions and contemporary flair, all without ever feeling contrived or overly quaint.
November 4, 2025
15.5/20
Italian$$
What made 2015 such a remarkable year for Melbourne's restaurant world? Was it something special in the air that sparked unprecedented inspiration and innovation? Perhaps it was a burst of collective creativity that turned our city into a hub of gastronomic excellence. That year saw the launch of numerous iconic venues that have shaped our dining landscape ever since.
Take Embla, for instance – a moody wine bar that epitomizes Melbourne's knack for blending sophistication with approachability. Or Marion, which redefined the wine bar experience with its modern twists. Anchovy dazzled us with its deeply personal take on Australian-Vietnamese fusion, proving how cultural blending can create something extraordinary. And Minamishima? It set a new benchmark for sushi, elevating Japanese fine dining to heights we hadn't imagined. The list of 2015's trailblazers is extensive and impressive.
But here's where it gets interesting: Amidst these high-profile openings, one restaurant from that golden year operates more quietly, yet it embodies a distinctive Melbourne spirit. Enter Trattoria Emilia, founded by chefs Francesco Rota and Luca Flammia, who arrived in Australia from Modena a few years prior. Their vision was to celebrate authentic Italian cuisine, specifically drawing from the rich traditions of Emilia-Romagna in northern Italy. For beginners curious about this region, Emilia-Romagna is famous for its hearty, flavorful dishes like fresh pasta, prosciutto, and balsamic vinegar – think comforting, soul-warming food that's all about quality ingredients and simple joys.
For the past decade, Trattoria Emilia has stayed true to this ethos, but there's an undeniable Melbourne energy in its lively atmosphere, playful yet polished service, and that carefree yet professional vibe. It could simply be that our city's hospitality style mirrors Italy's so closely – warm, welcoming, and full of life – making this fusion feel almost destined.
In 2024, the team expanded their offerings with Emilietta, a lunchtime sandwich spot in the bar area of the restaurant. This clever extension feels like a natural offshoot, seamlessly integrated into the main space.
Mid-year brought a change when Flammia departed, prompting a short closure in late September for a quick refresh. I must admit, I was concerned it might strip away some of that cherished, lived-in charm. Fortunately, those worries were unfounded.
Even keen observers might miss the subtle upgrades: a more open kitchen layout, fresh artwork, and new banquette seating along the back wall that accommodates more guests while giving tables some extra elbow room. The restaurant retains its intimate corners, thoughtful mix of table sizes, antique glass cabinets, and that overarching warmth that has always defined it.
The pasta here is beyond flawless – it's a testament to unparalleled skill in the craft, silky and precise in a way that only comes from mastering the art.
More crucially, it continues to deliver some of Melbourne's most confident Italian fare. Rota expertly navigates the delicate path between rustic earthiness and refined elegance, honoring tradition while embracing innovation, all without seeming gimmicky or rigidly conventional. He approaches ingredients, dishes, and techniques with a question: What's the ultimate way to express this? How can I maximize flavor, joy, and satisfaction from these elements?
Consider the generous bone marrow starter, a towering scoop of tender, gelatinous meat topped with chopped bitter rapini greens. Accompanied by a smear of fermented porcini mushrooms and crostini, it's an invitation to indulgence – just layer the marrow on toast and surrender to the decadence.
Then there's the rosy vitello tonnato, a classic dish that teaches the value of tradition. Its tuna mayonnaise, caper, and fried sage topping remind us that some ingenious combinations from the past simply can't be topped.
The pasta section is undeniably the menu's heartbeat. Right now, it's celebrating spring with delicate ricotta, zucchini, and leek-stuffed ravioli, draped in saffron sauce and adorned with zucchini flowers. The pasta dough itself is impeccably crafted – tight, silky, and so perfect it screams mastery.
The pork and beef tortelloni is a beloved signature for good reason; Rota's risotto is equally revelatory, with a brothy yet creamy texture packed with layered tastes. Currently, it marries citrus zest with oceanic notes: lemon, prawn, sea urchin, and bursts of salmon roe.
I truly value how Trattoria Emilia embraces inclusivity, offering a full vegan menu that's not an afterthought – it's so appealing that even meat-lovers might choose it. I particularly savored a roasted cauliflower main drizzled with pine nut and sesame sauce, and my dining companion appreciated that her preferences didn't complicate things for me.
This spirit of inclusion reflects the welcoming atmosphere overall. The service is gracious, entertaining, and endearing, maintaining its charm even in a crowded room, which is often the case.
While Trattoria Emilia might not be the most famous from Melbourne's 2015 crop, perhaps that's because it feels eternal, as if it's always belonged in this laneway. Fingers crossed it stays that way.
And this is the part most people miss: In a world where authenticity is hotly debated, does this Italian restaurant in Australia truly capture the essence of Emilia-Romagna, or has it morphed into something distinctly Melbourne? Is the blend of tradition and modernity a stroke of genius, or does it dilute the original flavors? What do you think – should global cuisines adapt to local tastes, or risk becoming relics? I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments; do you agree that this fusion is Melbourne's secret weapon, or disagree and believe in sticking rigidly to roots?
The low-down
Atmosphere: Cozy, vintage Italian-Australian allure with a lively buzz
Go-to dishes: Bone marrow ($27); risotto ($44); plin (ravioli, $40)
Drinks: Timeless Italian cocktails paired with an excellent wine selection featuring Italy's lesser-known regions
Cost: Roughly $170 for two, not including beverages
Good Food reviews are conducted anonymously and paid for independently. Restaurants cannot purchase reviews or placements in the Good Food Guide.
Stay updated with restaurant reviews, news, and the latest openings delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign up (https://login.myfairfax.com.au/signupnewsletter/10171?channelkey=4vLxp6nBuWVKEPLaQuUKwA&callback_uri=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theage.com.au)
From our partners
